Emails That Sell #1: The Cart Abandonment Conqueror (Horizn Studios)

Picture of Siim Pettai

Siim Pettai

Retention marketer for eCommerce brands
Emails That Sell #1 The Cart Abandonment Conqueror (Horizn Studios)

In this new content series, I’ll break down 100 emails from luxury and premium brands.

I will analyze them.

I will re-write them.

I will show you the before and after.

Now, before I jump into the first example, you might be wondering…

Why am I doing this?

I want to show how high-end brands can make more money and build deeper customer relationships just by writing better emails. 

The truth is this …

Your emails don’t have to look like an art gallery.

Your emails don’t have to sound like a corporate announcement. 

And you certainly don’t have to throw any discounts (or other gimmicks) at your customers.

You just have to present your products in an authentic, desirable way. 

In the first edition, I’m taking a look at the cart abandonment email of Horizn Studios, a premium luggage brand.

Let’s get started.

Original email:

Breakdown:

“Never have multiple call-to-actions in your email.” 

I’m not a big fan of rules. Most things are never that black and white.

But if there’s one “rule” that this email breaks, it’s to never overwhelm your reader with multiple call to actions.

When you look at the email at first glance, it’s confusing. 

There’s an option to check out.

There’s a button to “get in touch”.

There are also links to other product categories, social media, and the website. 

Which brings me to my point…

The goal of the cart abandonment email is to direct the user to finish the purchase.

That’s it. 

You don’t want them to visit your website for any other reason. 

The rest is just added friction.

Don’t add generic images to cart abandonment emails. 

For one, it takes focus away from the dynamic product.

It also makes the email look like it came from a large company trying to land a sale.

The more personal the email feels, the more likely you are to convert someone into a customer. 

Only use scarcity when it’s authentic

I don’t recommend using gimmick scarcity tactics like “secure before it’s gone” because it’s not believable. 

As a customer, I know immediately this is an automated cart abandonment email (which isn’t ideal). No matter which product I add to the cart, you’re going to tell me that.

There are much better ways to create desire for your product, such as using social proof, visual copy, or telling a story about how your products are made. 

“The customer is not a moron. She’s your wife.” – David Ogilvy.


New email:

Analysis:

When I researched the market, I found that many customers get burned by luggage companies.

They think what they’re buying is high quality, only for the luggage to get scratched or broken within the first use.

The last thing they want is something that they have to throw away or refund within a week.

They want luggage that will serve them for years to come. 

This made product quality the first objection to overcome in the email. 

Another thing I noticed about the target demographic is this:

These are ambitious, modern professionals traveling every week for work.

What are they looking for?

Luggage that makes them look ambitious, modern and professional.

Something that enhances their image. 

The best way to demonstrate it by showing, not telling.

If I were to start this email screaming about how great the luggage is, the words wouldn’t carry much weight.

A more reliable, effective, and persuasive method is to use social proof. 

Finally, notice how this emails solves customer questions?

I don’t guide the user to the website. Instead, I gave them them answers directly in the email.

If they have any other questions, they can respond directly to the email. 

No extra links. No added friction.

If there’s one thing I’d A/B test with this email, it would be removing the image and making it 100% plain-text.

The Before vs After:

The Pattern Breaker

32 Creative Email Campaign Angles Claude or ChatGPT Won’t Tell You

"

This One Email We Sent Did Crazy Numbers.

Peter W.
Copywriter, Hostage Tape