Emails that Sell #33: Eddie Shleyner’s Storytelling Technique (August)

Picture of Siim Pettai

Siim Pettai

Retention marketer for eCommerce brands

This story-based email campaign by August is an excellent example of painting a vivid picture of a nightmare scenario in the customer’s life. This completely reframes the USP —> August doesn’t sell 100% organic cotton tampons —> they sell peace of mind. 


“Now I work in copywriting, and moments are everything.
Zoom in on the moment, and it will speak for itself.”

– Eddie Shleyner, VeryGoodCopy

SL: Don’t get caught off guard during the holidays

Eddie Shleyn

Get Notified of Each Breakdown

Key takeaways:

  • Storytelling emails don’t have to be long. Set the scene with facts (e.g., you’re at the great-aunt’s house), introduce conflict early, and deliver the “a-ha” moment.
  • A lowercase subject line is the first sign the email was written by an actual human
  • The best emails focus on ONE key idea. 
  • Most brands can and should use humor in their email copy 
  • When communicating product benefits, ask yourself, “So what?” This reveals the real value proposition.

What’s next:

What’s one moment your product transforms? Make it hyper-specific.

The Pattern Breaker

32 Creative Email Campaign Angles Claude or ChatGPT Won’t Tell You

"

This One Email We Sent Did Crazy Numbers.

Peter W.
Copywriter, Hostage Tape