I’m not much of a drinker.
In fact, it’s March 11th, 2025 as I’m writing this, and I haven’t had a sip of alcohol this year.
It’s not a 75-hard challenge.
I just can’t be bothered.
I look at alcohol the same way I look at energy drinks.
They’re good – some are even delicious.
But is the high worth the low that comes after?
For me, 99 times out of 100, the answer is no.
Now, before you say “You must be fun at parties,” I do occasionally indulge in a drink.
But when I do, it sure as hell ain’t whisky.
I remember taking my first sip of whisky and thinking: “This must be what my wooden floor tastes like.”
I haven’t had whisky since.
Any whisky fan reading this right now is screaming…
bRo, YoU JuSt HaVen’T HaD A sInGle MaLt fRoM a sHiPpErD’s BaRrEl aGed iN tHe ScOtTiSh HiGhLaNdS.
I know… I know.
That being said…
I can still appreciate a well-written email about whisky.
Today, I’ll break down a cart abandonment email from Whisky Loot.
This email is a great example of recovering a sale without throwing in a gimmicky discount.
All it takes is some brand storytelling and clear, persuasive copy.
Let’s dive into it.
But before…
What is Emails That Sell?
Each week, I break down an email from a DTC brand. Some of these brands are absolutely killing it when it comes to email marketing.
I also want to show you examples of the conventional way of doing email marketing — with discounts and other mass-market tactics.
If you have an email you want me to break down, send it over to me on LinkedIn or at marketing@siimpettai.com
Now, let’s get down to business…
Let’s begin with the subject line:
“Your cart is sobering up”
I mean, lol.
That’s pretty funny.
And for me, that’s already enough to get the email opened.
Just imagine the ocean of emails you receive every day:
Most of them will say:
“Buy now – 15% off!”
“Last chance – 10% off”
Then there’s an email from Whisky Loot:
“Your cart is sobering up”
It stands out. It’s unique.
Key takeaway #1: Don’t be afraid to use humor
Key takeaway #2: Make your subject line stand out
Now, there’s so much to dissect from the actual email copy.
I like that the email starts with a question:
“Still thinking about it?”
It’s short and relevant enough to keep me reading.
But then, Whisky Loot uses vivid language to make you imagine certain moments:
“Drink really really slowly”
“Become a whisky expert at trivia nights”
“Drink them while winning at Poker”
I’m not a whisky fan, and even I can imagine myself in these situations, with a glass of Whisky Loot in my hands.
Of course, they added some funny bullets as well:
“Take them to a dinner party and don’t share them”
“Drink and swirl like it’s Listerine”
“Use them as collateral in peace negotiations”
It’s a combination of real moments, humor, and benefits that work well together.
Key takeaway #3: Make the reader imagine real-life moments
I also think adding an unboxed image of the product is a smart idea.
If you think about it, it’s essentially the POV you see as you unbox your whisky box.
It makes me think I’ve already ordered a package from Whisky Loot, and I’m just waiting for it to arrive.
Key takeaway #4: Use an unboxing image of your product
Finally, I love that they answered frequently asked questions IN the email.
So many brands add links, separate contact details, etc. – it’s just unnecessary friction.
And let me tell you something:
Friction = lost sales
Always offer the reader a chance to reply to the email and ask a question.
That’s the only way it should be in cart abandonment emails.
Key takeaway #5: Answer FAQs in the email
When I look at the questions, I love they let you know exactly what you’re getting:
“You receive 3 x 60 ML bottles of high-quality premium whisky from around the world. Each box contains a minimum bottle price of $300 worth of whiskey.”
The email also removes the risk of buying:
“On the 14th of next month, we’ll notify you of what’s included in the upcoming month’s box – simply skip before the 20th and you won’t be charged.”
This completely removes the risk in case I don’t want the box that particular month, or if I just want to try it the first month.
Key takeaway #6: Remove the risk of buying
Finally, there’s just one call to action.
Now, you’d think that’s common sense.
Think again.
You’d be surprised to know how many brands have 3-5 links in their cart abandonment email, inviting you to shop for other products, check out their Instagram, or whatever.
A cart abandonment email’s objective is to recover a sale – limit your call to action to that.
Key takeaway #7: Use one call-to-action
To recap:
TL;DR
Key takeaway #1: Don’t be afraid to use humor
Key takeaway #2: Make your subject line stand out
Key takeaway #3: Make the reader imagine real-life moments
Key takeaway #4: Use an unboxing image of your product
Key takeaway #5: Answer FAQs in the email
Key takeaway #6: Remove the risk of buying
Key takeaway #7: Use one call-to-action
Next week
We’ll dive into a plain-text re-engagement campaign. This is great if you have a bunch of non-buyers on your email list, and you want to send one more campaign before cleaning your list. After a welcome sequence, converting subscribers into customers becomes more difficult. I’ll show you a way how you can do it.
Here’s what’s next: