Flows That Sell #1: How To Recover Abandoned Carts Without Discounts (Graza)

Picture of Siim Pettai

Siim Pettai

Retention marketer for eCommerce brands

Graza makes $50M/yr selling olive oil.

This is a breakdown of their cart abandonment flow.

In this analysis, you’ll learn:

  • How many cart abandonment emails should you send
  • How to use social proof the right way
  • How to stand out and sell without discounts

But before we dive in…

What is Flows That Sell?

In this content series, I break down email automation flows from DTC e-commerce brands. Expect to learn different copywriting techniques, sales psychology, and consumer behavior — everything that moves you away from hard-selling discount campaigns and other mass-market tactics.

For more in-depth email analysis, check out Emails that Sell.

Or if you need help with setting up email automations for your brand, get in touch with me here.

Let’s get into it now:

Email 1:

Subject line: Your kitchen deserves MICHELIN STAR OLIVE OIL

Angle: Reminder + social proof

Time delay: 1 hour

Graza Cart Abandonment Email Example

Analysis:

Remember, the first email in your cart abandonment flow acts as a reminder more than anything else. The hero section (above the fold) isn’t trying to convince you. Having a large CTA button there is smart. 

If you do scroll, you’ll be presented with a testimonial. Notice the review precisely targets someone who’d have objections about buying:

“I was super skeptical and just thought it was millennial marketing. This olive oil surpassed every expectation I had.”

When you use social proof, always try to make it as relevant as possible.

Email 2:

Subject line: Roast! Sear! Dip! DRIZZLE!

Angle: Use cases

Time delay: 48 hours

Cart abandonment email by Graza

Analysis:

I like the short, punchy subject lines. 

At first glance, this email doesn’t even look like a cart abandonment email. It doesn’t mention anything about returning to your cart. I think that’s a good thing!

This email is much more visual and shows what the product can do — elevate already delicious plates to another level. 

Email 3:

Subject line: Roast! Sear! Dip! DRIZZLE!

Time delay: 5 days

Angle: reminder

Plain text cart abandonment email Graza

Analysis:

This email is a complete pattern breaker from the previous ones. It’s conversational, personal, and human. If you read it out loud, it sounds like a friend reaching out to you. That’s exactly what you want!

No matter what you sell, every brand should have a plain text email in their cart abandonment flow. 

And notice, again, there are no discounts. It subtly mentions the olive oil is “crazy fresh,” and “antioxidant-packed,” but it’s not overly salesy.

I just wish they sent it from an actual person (a founder or someone else).

Takeaways:

Key takeaway #1: Use short, punchy subject lines.

Key takeaway #2: Add social proof, but make it relevant.

Key takeaway #3: Send the first follow-up within an hour.

Key takeaway #4: Most people abandon carts not because they lost interest, but because life happened.

Key takeaway #5: Have large CTAs (especially above the fold) in designed emails

Key takeaway #6: Throw in a plain-text email (ideally from the founder)

Key takeaway #7: Make your emails fun and conversational

Key takeaway #8: Have at least three emails in your cart abandonment flow

What’s next

Have a look at your current cart abandonment flow. Can you throw in a plain-text email? Can you add an extra follow-up?

If you’re currently offering discounts, I suggest you remove them and see if the conversions go down. More often than not, that’s not actually the case!

If you haven’t already, subscribe to my email list and get notified of every Emails That Sell analysis + my weekly newsletter.

And if you need help with setting up email automations for your brand, get in touch with me here.

The Pattern Breaker

32 Creative Email Campaign Angles Claude or ChatGPT Won’t Tell You

"

This One Email We Sent Did Crazy Numbers.

Peter W.
Copywriter, Hostage Tape