Emails That Sell #2: When You Shouldn’t Think Like a Copywriter (Karma and Luck)

Picture of Siim Pettai

Siim Pettai

Retention marketer for eCommerce brands
Emails That Sell (2_100)_ When You Shouldn’t Think Like a Copywriter (Karma and Luck)

Here I’ll break down a cart abandonment email sent to me by Karma and Luck, a spiritual lifestyle brand selling timeless jewelry and home decor.

This one is a bit different. Unlike the previous email where I used a copywriting framework, I’ll show why thinking like a copywriter isn’t always the best idea.

Let’s get into it.

Original email:

Karma and Luck checkout abandonment email.

Breakdown:

At first glance, this email checks most of the boxes.

It’s on-brand. It’s easy to read. It talks about the craftsmanship of the products. There’s a clear call to action.

And you know what… I actually like that it doesn’t rely on sales tactics or scarcity gimmicks.

Wait what… a copywriter telling me I shouldn’t use sales techniques?

For one, they’re overused, especially in cart abandonment emails. Customers see right through them.

But most importantly, we’re talking about a spiritual lifestyle brand with products designed to increase purpose, happiness, and connection in people’s lives.

The email should read as if it was written by a yoga teacher who is concerned because you signed up for a class but have not shown up in two weeks. 

And guess what?

Concerned yoga teachers don’t use sales tactics or copywriting techniques. 

They simply check in with you.

Which brings me to the main critique I have for this email. 

Design-heavy emails lack personal connection. 

Cart abandonment emails, especially from a brand like this, should be all about connection.

I’ve tested this on my clients, and the increase in engagement and conversions is significant.

At the moment, the email gives off the impression that it was sent by a large corporation hoping to close a sale.

It doesn’t give the reader any option to reach out or ask questions. Which means if they have doubts about the product, shipping, or payment options, they have to open a new tab, type in the website, look for the support section, find an email address, and write to them.

That’s a lotta friction if you ask me. 

Let’s take a look at the updated email…

New email:

Luxury brand cart abandonment email.

Breakdown:

I enjoyed writing this email because the target audience is deeply connected through identity — people who believe spirituality leads to deeper meaning, prosperity, and happiness.

Remember the part about the yoga teacher?

Yeah. 

This is how I’d imagine the email to sound like.

First off, I give a reason why I’m reaching out (unfinished order).

I reassure the reader if they have any doubts, they can simply reach out.

I let them know that each of the items is handcrafted with intention and purpose. 

I include social proof, saying that many people instantly feel a connection to their pieces once they receive them.

I finish with a benefit saying the item will help them move forward in their spiritual journey.  

Finally, notice how I removed all the distracting links.

You only have three choices with this email:

You can reply with a question.

You can finish your purchase.

Or you can click off. 

The easiest way to increase conversions is to decrease friction. 

 

The Pattern Breaker

32 Creative Email Campaign Angles Claude or ChatGPT Won’t Tell You

"

This One Email We Sent Did Crazy Numbers.

Peter W.
Copywriter, Hostage Tape