Emails That Sell #6: Plain-Text Re-Engagement Emails (Eight Sleep)

Picture of Siim Pettai

Siim Pettai

Retention marketer for eCommerce brands
Plain-Text-Re-Engagement-Emails-Eight-Sleep.

Do you own one of those sleep trackers?

I bet ya do.

Here’s what mine said the other day about my sleep quality:

“Poor”

“Poor”

“Average”

“Poor”

“Average”

Turns out, even though the duration of my sleep was fine, the quality of my sleep was low.

What was the issue? 

I didn’t get enough deep sleep.

There were days when I’d sleep for a total of 8.5 hours, but spend 45 minutes in deep sleep.

That’s 8.8% 

Rookie numbers. 

Now looking back, it makes sense…

I would go to bed and scroll through my phone for half an hour.

I’d check the clock during the night and blast blue light into my face. 

I’d eat a huge meal one hour before bed.

Most of the things you’d need to do (or not do) to set yourself up for a good night’s sleep, I wasn’t doing. 

As soon as I started taking sleep hygiene seriously, things changed.

I was able to think more clearly.

Most importantly, I wasn’t constantly living on the edge.

Great sleep is life-changing.

Today, we’re looking at a few plain-text emails from Eight Sleep.

Wait? What?

A high-end brand consciously deciding to send “ugly” looking emails that actually feel personal and make more money?

That’s right.

If you haven’t heard of Eight Sleep, it’s a hi-tech mattress that helps you sleep better.

It can do all kinds of cool stuff, like regulate your sleeping temperature, track snoring, and adjust elevation.

Honestly, if the thing wasn’t so damn expensive, I would have probably bought one right now.

Maybe one day I become rich and I get myself one of these mattresses. 

Or eventually I just come to terms with the fact I have to invest an UNCOMFORTABLY LARGE CHUNK of my net worth to save my sleep. 

Anyway, the emails I’m about to show you are a perfect way to build a relationship with your audience while soft-selling your products. 

Let’s dive into it…

But before: 

What is Emails That Sell?

Each week, I break down an email from a DTC brand. Some of these brands are absolutely killing it when it comes to email marketing. 

I also want to show you examples of the conventional way of doing email marketing — with discounts and other mass-market tactics. In some cases, I rewrite these emails. I’m not claiming my emails are the best — I’m not an expert on these brands, and my research is limited. I’m simply giving you an idea of how you can sell luxury products without selling your soul and damaging your brand reputation with gimmicks and discounts. 

If you have an email you want me to break down, send it over to me on LinkedIn or at marketing@siimpettai.com

Now, let’s get down to business…

It’s worth mentioning that I’ve been on Eight Sleep’s email list for over a year, and I haven’t made a single purchase.

Yet, they still send me emails like this every week. I love it!

As usual, let’s begin with the subject line:

“Want to sleep like a champion?”

It gets me to say “Yes!” immediately.

One of my takeaways from Cialdini’s and Dale Carnegie’s books is to get a positive response from the audience as soon as possible.

Once you get your reader to say “Yes”, it makes it easier to transition into a sale later.

Contrarily, if you start with a negative response, their whole existence turns into rejection mode. 

Key takeaway #1: Get them to say “Yes” immediately.

Now, as soon as I open the email, I want to take my hat off to anyone who wrote this (Abby?).

Notice the links!

There are one, two, three, four, FIVE links around the same call-to-action.

Remember this:

You’re not there to make the sale on the spot.

Your email exists to guide them to the next step.

You should never assume someone will read your entire email and click on the final CTA.

Key takeaway #2: Add links throughout your body copy.

The email looks like it was written by a colleague or a close friend. 

And that’s really the great thing about plain-text emails – they feel personal.

Plain text also allows you to attach a name to your email, like this one. 

You can send it from an actual human, like Abby, instead of from Eight Sleep. 

Key takeaway #3: Attach a name to your email.

Now, the body copy:

I like that it aims to educate the reader first. 

Many brands would just design an offer banner “Try 30 days risk-free” and blast it into my face.

But not Eight Sleep.

They understand I’m not ready to buy yet, so they use subtle reminders like “Recovery is just as important as training” and “Sleep is where your body rebuilds” to get me to buy. 

It also makes for a smooth transition and a compelling reason why they created their product. 

Key takeaway #4: Provide value first, then sell.

It then takes simple product features and frames them as benefits:

Customer temperature control → deeper sleep and ultimate comfort

Gentle vibration and thermal alarm → energized mornings

Advanced sleep tracking → optimize your recovery

Features into benefits is such a basic copywriting concept, but it’s still pretty damn effective.

The only thing I would do is try to dimensionalize the benefits.

For each benefit, I’d dig deeper and ask “So what?”

Here’s an example:

Custom temperature control —> Ultimate comfort

So what?

Less tossing and turning.

So what?

Wake up energized in the morning.

So what?

Start the day in a great mood.

So what?

You’ll have a productive day at work.

Does your audience want great sleep, or does great sleep allow them to crush it at work?

Key takeaway #5: Dimensionalize the benefits.

Let’s see how Abby transitions to the final CTA:

The only thing I would add here is to drop one name of a champion who uses Eight Sleep.

Right now it doesn’t connect any high-performance athletes to the product, so the effect of social proof isn’t that strong.

However, the final CTA is effective. 

Notice that they’re not asking me to buy the mattress.

They’re offering me to TRY it.

It’s a soft sell, as it should be when you’re sending emails to non-buyers.

And here’s the best part:

They’re offering a guarantee to go with it.

If I don’t like the product after 30 days, I can send it back for free.

Key takeaway #6: Make it easy to try your product by offering a guarantee.

All in all, this email is a great example of how to get non-buyers over the hump (or at least try your product).

I would try something like this especially if you’re cleaning your email list but want to send a few re-engagement campaigns.

Great job, Eight Sleep!

To recap:

TL;DR

Key takeaway #1: Get them to say “Yes” immediately.

Key takeaway #2: Add links throughout your body copy.

Key takeaway #3: Attach a name to your email.

Key takeaway #4: Provide value first, then sell.

Key takeaway #5: Dimensionalize the benefits.

Key takeaway #6: Make it easy to try your product by offering a guarantee.

Next week

We’ll dive into an email from a British luxury fashion brand. If you’re looking to create a visual and reliable email template for your weekly campaigns, you’re going to love this one.

Here’s what’s next:

Subscribe to my email list below and get notified of every Emails That Sell analysis. 

Read more: 

Emails That Sell #3: A Lil Word Painting Goes a Long Way (Carl Friedrik)

Emails that Sell #4: How to Communicate Your Unique Mechanism

Emails That Sell #5: The No Discount Cart Abandonment Email (Whisky Loot)

The Pattern Breaker

32 Creative Email Campaign Angles Claude or ChatGPT Won’t Tell You

"

This One Email We Sent Did Crazy Numbers.

Peter W.
Copywriter, Hostage Tape